The College Sports Communicators (CSC; formerly College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA)) annually selects Academic All-America® Teams in 16 programs – football, men’s soccer, women’s soccer, and volleyball in the fall, men’s basketball, women’s basketball, men's swimming & diving, and women's swimming & diving in the winter, baseball, softball, men's tennis, women's tennis, men’s track/cross country, and women’s track/cross country as well as men’s at-large sports and women’s at-large sports in the spring. At-large sports include crew, fencing, field hockey, golf, gymnastics, ice hockey, lacrosse, rifle, skiing, and water polo and included swimming & diving and tennis until the 2022-23 academic year. Starting in 2011-12, a first-team, second-team, and third-team are selected in NCAA Div. I, II, and III, and NAIA (football consists of just first- and second-teams). Prior to that, they were broken down by University (NCAA Div. I and I-AA) and College (NCAA Div. II and III, and NAIA) Divisions.
Here is a list of Wooster's 62 Academic All-Americans®, broken down by year.
| Name | Sport | Year (Honor) |
| Dave Foy | Football | 1973 |
| Blake Moore | Football | 1977 |
| Blake Moore | Football | 1978 |
| Blake Moore | Football | 1979 |
| Dale Fortner | Football | 1980 |
| John Weisensell | Football | 1980 |
| Tim Kelly | Baseball | 1981 |
| Karen Light | Volleyball | 1984 (1st) |
| Nora Land | Volleyball | 1985 (2nd) |
| Lisa Diment | Women’s Basketball | 1986 (HM) |
| Matt Hiestand | Baseball | 1988 (2nd) |
| Carissa Conner | Women’s At-Large (Field Hockey) | 1992 (3rd) |
| Eric Hicks | Men’s At-Large (Tennis) | 1992 (1st) |
| Matt Mahaffey | Football | 1998 (2nd) |
| Matt Mahaffey | Football | 1999 (1st) |
| Ryan Hartschuh | Football | 2002 (2nd) |
| Kayla Heising | Women’s At-Large (Swimming) | 2003 (1st) |
| Kayla Heising | Women’s At-Large (Swimming) | 2004 (2nd) |
| Matt Schlingman | Men’s Basketball | 2004 (2nd) |
| Matt Schlingman | Men’s Basketball | 2005 (1st) |
| Katie Wieferich | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2006 (2nd) |
| Rick Drushal | Football | 2006 (1st) |
| Tim Presto | Men's Soccer | 2006 (1st) |
| Sheldon Steiner | Baseball | 2007 (2nd) |
| Katie Wieferich | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2007 (2nd) |
| Jay Keener | Men's Soccer | 2008 (3rd) |
| Chantal Koechli | Women's Soccer | 2008 (1st) |
| Ryan Story | Men's At-Large (Lacrosse) | 2009 (3rd) |
| Jay Keener | Men's Soccer | 2009 (1st) |
| Chantal Koechli | Women's Soccer | 2009 (1st) |
| Ryan Story | Men's At-Large (Lacrosse) | 2010 (1st) |
| Paige Piper | Women's Soccer | 2010 (3rd) |
| Erin Plews-Ogan | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2011 (3rd) |
| Kelsey Peters | Women's Soccer | 2011 (2nd) |
| Paige Piper | Women's Soccer | 2011 (1st) |
| Kelsie Herring | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2012 (2nd) |
| Erin Plews-Ogan | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2012 (2nd) |
| Paige Piper | Women's Soccer | 2012 (2nd) |
| Kelley Johnson | Volleyball | 2012 (1st) |
| Shawna Ferris | Women's At-Large (Lacrosse) | 2013 (1st) |
| Erin Plews-Ogan | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2013 (1st) |
| Jarrod Mancine | Baseball | 2014 (2nd) |
| Nick Flannery | Football | 2014 (1st) |
| Tyler Gerwig | Football | 2014 (1st) |
| Morgan Hughes | Women's At-Large (Swimming) | 2015 (3rd) |
| Joe David | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2015 (3rd) |
| Nick Flannery | Football | 2015 (1st) |
| Geoffrey Carney-Knisely | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2017 (3rd) |
| Geoffrey Carney-Knisely | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2018 (1st) |
| Eric Kraus | Football | 2019 (2nd) |
| Harry Witwer-Dukes | Baseball | 2020 (3rd) |
| Tyler Chumita | Baseball | 2021 (2nd) |
| Alexa Bencic | Women's Soccer | 2021 (3rd) |
| Lake Barrett | Football | 2021 (1st) |
| Katie Billetdeaux | Volleyball | 2021 (3rd) |
| Syd Case | Volleyball | 2021 (1st) |
| Michael Thomas | Baseball | 2022 (2nd) |
| Will McMichael | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2022 (3rd) |
| Matt Ulishney | Football | 2022 (1st) |
| Lake Barrett | Football | 2022 (2nd) |
| Matt Pardi | Football | 2022 (2nd) |
| Shane Epstein-Petrullo | Men's Lacrosse | 2023 (3rd) |
| Lake Barrett | Football | 2023 (1st) |
Key
1st indicates first-team honoree
2nd indicates second-team honoree
3rd indicates third-team honoree
HM indicates honorable mention selection