| Name | Position | Year (Team) |
| CoSIDA (since 1978) | ||
| Dave Baka | Placekicker | 1986 (HM) |
| Geoff Belz | Linebacker | 1989 (HM) |
| Seth Duerr | Linebacker | 1998 (HM), 1999 (1st), 2000 (1st) |
| Brian Grandison | Running Back | 1989 (HM) |
| Nick Hajjar | Defensive Back | 2003 (HM) |
| Return Specialist | 2002 (HM) | |
| Brock Jones | Defensive End | 1985 (HM), 1986 (HM), 1987 (HM) |
| Matt Mahaffey | Punter | 1998 (3rd) |
| Seth Mastrine | Defensive Back | 1999 (HM), 2000 (3rd) |
| Chad Peterman | Offensive Lineman | 1999 (2nd) |
| Jon Spragg | Offensive Lineman | 2002 (HM) |
| Tony Sutton | Running Back | 2002 (HM), 2003 (1st) |
| Mike Woltman | Tight End | 1987 (HM) |
| Associated Press (since 1934) | ||
| Rick Drushal | Offensive Line | 2006 (2nd) |
| Seth Duerr | Linebacker | 1999 (2nd) |
| Dale Fortner | Defensive Back | 1979 (2nd), 1980 (HM) |
| Tony Harris | Linebacker | 1987 (HM) |
| Cole Hissong | Tight End | 2021 (2nd) |
| Blake Moore | Offensive Line | 1978 (HM), 1979 (1st) |
| Karl Penn | Linebacker | 1987 (HM) |
| Eric Showes | Defensive End | 1978 (HM) |
| Tony Sutton | Running Back | 2003 (1st), 2004 (1st) |
| AFCA Coaches (since 1967) | ||
| Rick Drushal | Offensive Line | 2006 |
| Seth Duerr | Linebacker | 1999 |
| Blake Moore | Offensive Line | 1979 |
| Tony Sutton | Running Back | 2003, 2004 |
| D3Football.com (since 1999) | ||
| Ryan Dansak | Offensive Line | 1999 (3rd) |
| Rick Drushal | Offensive Line | 2005 (HM) |
| Seth Duerr | Linebacker | 2000 (2nd) |
| Nick Hajjar | Defensive Back | 2002 (3rd), 2003 (HM) |
| Cole Hissong | Tight End | 2021 (2nd) |
| Brandon James | Special Teams | 2015 (3rd) |
| Joe Kearney | Defensive Tackle | 2004 (1st) |
| Matt Mahaffey | Punter | 1999 (3rd) |
| Andy Mizak | Defensive End | 2004 (HM) |
| Chad Peterman | Offensive Line | 1999 (2nd) |
| Jon Spragg | Offensive Line | 2002 (2nd) |
| Tony Sutton | Running Back | 2003 (1st), 2004 (1st) |
| Dan Terhune | Defensive Tackle | 2010 (2nd) |
| Jim Wallace | Offensive Line | 2004 (2nd) |
| Football Gazette (since 1993) | ||
| Seth Duerr | Linebacker | 1999 (HM), 2000 (1st) |
| Rick Drushal | Offensive Line | 2004 (2nd) |
| Matt Mahaffey | Punter | 1999 (HM) |
| Seth Mastrine | Defensive Back | 2000 (3rd) |
| Chad Peterman | Offensive Line | 1999 (2nd) |
| Tony Sutton | Running Back | 2003 (1st), 2004 (1st) |
