College of Wooster Baseball All-Americans
| Name | Position | Year (Team) |
| ABCA Coaches | (since 1976) | |
| Brett Beech | Pitcher | 1994 (3rd) |
| Drew Binkowski | Pitcher | 1998 (3rd) |
| Brent Bizyak | Outfield | 1989 (1st) |
| Pat Christensen | Outfield | 2005 (2nd) |
| Tyler Chumita | Shortstop | 2021 (3rd) |
| Chris Cingolani | First Base | 1994 (1st) |
| Russ Crawford | Outfield | 1979 (1st) |
| Chandler Dippman | Utility | 2018 (2nd) |
| Matt Englander | Pitcher | 2001 (2nd), 2002 (3rd) |
| Jake Frank | Third Base | 2003 (1st), 2004 (3rd), 2005 (1st) |
| Ben Gbur | Outfield | 2022 (1st) |
| Terry Gladis | Outfield | 1994 (2nd) |
| Matt Groezinger | First Base | 2009 (1st) |
| Dan Harwood | Designated Hitter | 2018 (2nd), 2019 (2nd) |
| Matt Hiestand | First Base | 1990 (2nd) |
| Matt Jackson | Catcher | 1996 (1st), 1997 (1st) |
| Matthew Johnson | Second Base | 2010 (3rd) |
| Kurt Kapferer | Designated Hitter | 2006 (1st) |
| Sean Karpen | Outfielder | 2009 (2nd) |
| Tim Kelly | Catcher | 1980 (3rd) |
| Dave Kessler | First Base | 1986 (1st) |
| Mike Knox | Shortstop | 1980 (2nd) |
| Ryan Kramer | Designated Hitter | 2024 (2nd) |
| Jamie Lackner | First Base | 2015 (1st), 2016 (2nd), 2017 (1st) |
| Justin McDowell | Pitcher | 2009 (2nd) |
| Mark Miller | Pitcher | 2009 (1st) |
| Matt Miller | Second Base | 2004 (1st) |
| Jon Oliver | Pitcher | 2005 (2nd) |
| Dan Penberthy | First Base | 2001 (1st) |
| Rob Piscetta | Pitcher | 1987 (3rd) |
| Eddie Reese | Second Base | 2013 (2nd) |
| Adam Samson | Pitcher | 2007 (1st) |
| Rick Sforzo | Third Base/Shortstop | 1985 (3rd), 1986 (1st), 1987 (1st) |
| Luke Ullman | Shortstop | 2005 (1st / Div. III Player-of-the-Year) |
| Trevor Urban | Outfielder | 1997 (2nd), 1998 (1st) |
| Greg Van Horn | Shortstop | 2010 (3rd) |
| Frank Vance | Third Base | 2015 (2nd) |
| Michael Wielansky | Shortstop | 2017 (1st), 2018 (1st) |
| Harry Witwer-Dukes | Second Base | 2019 (1st) |
| D3baseball.com | (since 2007) | |
| Tyler Chumita | Shortstop | 2022 (5th) |
| Matt Groezinger | Designated Hitter | 2009 (1st) |
| Dan Harwood | Designated Hitter | 2018 (2nd), 2019 (1st) |
| Ryan Kramer | Designated Hitter | 2024 (2nd) |
| Matthew Johnson | Second Base | 2010 (HM) |
| Jamie Lackner | First Base | 2015 (2nd), 2017 (2nd) |
| Justin McDowell | Pitcher | 2009 (1st) |
| Mark Miller | Pitcher | 2008 (3rd) |
| Eddie Reese | Second Base | 2013 (2nd) |
| Adam Samson | Pitcher | 2007 (2nd) |
| Greg Van Horn | Shortstop | 2010 (3rd), 2011 (3rd) |
| Frank Vance | Third Base | 2015 (3rd) |
| Eli Westrick | Second Base | 2023 (4th) |
| Keenan White | Pitcher | 2013 (HM) |
| Michael Wielansky | Shortstop | 2018 (1st) |
| Harry Witwer-Dukes | Second Base | 2019 (2nd) |