| Name | Position | Year (Team) |
| NABC Coaches | (since 1960-61) | |
| Wayne Allison | Guard | 1977-78 (3rd) |
| Stan Aukamp | Center | 1991-92 (2nd) |
| James Cooper | Guard | 2005-06 (3rd), 2007-08 (2nd) |
| Tom Dinger | Guard | 1970-71 (3rd) |
| John Ellenwood | Center | 1999-00 (2nd) |
| Ian Franks | Guard | 2009-10 (1st), 2010-11 (3rd) |
| Ryan Gorman | Forward | 1997-98 (2nd) |
| Bill Gribble | Guard | 1965-66 (HM) |
| Danyon Hempy | Guard | 2019-20 (1st) |
| Bryan Nelson | Center | 2002-03 (1st / Div. III National Player-of-the-Year) |
| Tom Port | Forward | 2006-07 (1st) |
| Rich Thomas | Guard | 1960-61 (HM) |
| Doug Thorpe | Guard | 2013-14 (1st) |
| D3hoops.com | (since 1997-98) | |
| Xavier Brown | Guard | 2013-14 (3rd) |
| James Cooper | Guard | 2005-06 (HM), 2006-07 (2nd), 2007-08 (1st) |
| Ian Franks | Guard | 2009-10 (4th), 2010-11 (1st) |
| Justin Hallowell | Forward | 2011-12 (3rd) |
| Bryan Nelson | Center | 2002-03 (4th) |
| Tom Port | Forward | 2005-06 (4th), 2006-07 (2nd) |
